Instacart Los Angeles: Bad Faith Insurance in 2024

Listen to this article · 10 min listen

When you’re in an Instacart motorcycle crash in Los Angeles, the crash itself is just the beginning. The second fight, the one with the insurance companies, can be even more disorienting. They flood you with bad information and myths about “bad faith” practices, all designed to make you feel powerless against their corporate machine.

Key Takeaways

  • Insurance companies are legally required to act in good faith, that means investigating quickly and offering fair settlements.
  • A “bad faith” claim arises when an insurer unreasonably delays, denies, or lowballs a valid claim, and it can entitle you to more damages.
  • California Insurance Code Section 790.03 specifically lists the unfair settlement practices that are considered bad faith.
  • Documenting every single conversation with your insurer and getting legal advice early are the most important things you can do to protect yourself after an Instacart motorcycle accident.
  • Instacart’s insurance for shoppers is a tangled mess, with different layers of coverage that kick in (or don’t) depending on what you were doing in the app when the crash happened.
Bad Faith Insurance Practices
Unreasonable Delay

Common

Denying Valid Claim

Clear Instance

Underpaying Valid Claim

Frequent

Misrepresenting Policy

Subtle Tactic

Excessive Documentation

Delay Tactic

Myth 1: Insurance Companies Are Always on Your Side After an Accident

This is a common and dangerous myth. People assume that since they’ve paid their premiums for years, their insurer will have their back after a serious Instacart motorcycle crash on the 405 near the Getty Center. That’s just not how it works. Insurance companies are for-profit businesses, and they make money by minimizing what they pay out. Their adjusters are professional negotiators whose entire job is to find reasons to reduce what you’re owed or deny the claim completely, even when it’s totally legitimate. Don’t be fooled by a friendly tone on the phone. Their actions rarely match their sympathetic words.

The law says insurers have a duty of good faith, which means they’re supposed to handle claims fairly and promptly. The problem is, their definition of “fair” and yours are often worlds apart. When an insurer breaks this duty, you may have a bad faith claim. For example, say an Instacart shopper gets hit on Sepulveda Boulevard, breaks a leg, and sends in all the hospital bills, but the insurer comes back with an offer for 10% of the cost with no good explanation. That’s a huge red flag. California Insurance Code Section 790.03 spells out exactly what counts as unfair, including lying about what your policy covers, taking forever to say yes or no on coverage, or lowballing a settlement for far less than any reasonable person would expect.

Myth 2: You Don’t Need to Document Everything. The Insurance Company Will Handle It

This is completely wrong. Letting the insurance company be the sole record-keeper of your accident and injuries is asking for trouble. After an Instacart motorcycle crash in Los Angeles, especially in a chaotic spot like Hollywood, you have to become the lead investigator for your own case. Sure, the insurance company will send an adjuster, but that person is collecting evidence to protect the company’s money, not to help you. They’ll conveniently “overlook” evidence that helps you and find ways to downplay how bad your injuries really are.

Your own documentation is the best weapon you have against these tactics. This means you take photos and videos of everything at the scene, the damage to your bike, the other car, skid marks, traffic signals, and your injuries. You get names and numbers for every witness and cop. You keep a folder with every single medical bill, prescription receipt, and record of any money you spent because of the crash. I tell my clients to keep a simple journal about their pain levels and how the injuries are messing up their daily life (can’t work, can’t sleep, etc.). And you log every single interaction with the insurance company: date, time, who you spoke to, and what they said. If you talk on the phone, immediately send a follow-up email confirming the conversation. Without your own mountain of evidence, as the California Department of Insurance often reminds consumers (insurance.ca.gov), you have almost no use to fight an unfair offer.

Myth 3: Bad Faith Only Happens When an Insurer Flat-Out Denies a Claim

A lot of people think bad faith is just when an insurance company flatly denies a valid claim. That’s definitely bad faith, but it’s not the only way they do it. Most of the time, bad faith insurance practices are much sneakier. They come in a dozen different forms that, while not an outright “no,” still leave you holding the bag financially. Think about an Instacart shopper who gets rear-ended on Sunset Boulevard and suffers a serious spinal injury. The insurer might accept the claim, but then they start the games: they “lose” the paperwork you sent, they demand duplicate and irrelevant records to drag out the investigation for months, or they make a laughably low offer that doesn’t even cover the ER visit, let alone the surgery and physical therapy you’ll need for the next year. This is all bad faith.

Another classic tactic is to lie about what your policy covers or what the law says. An adjuster might tell you that a certain medical procedure isn’t covered, hoping you won’t read the fine print of your own policy. Or they’ll pressure you to sign a full release for a tiny check before you even know the full extent of your injuries and their long-term consequences. What is the key to proving bad faith? It’s about showing the insurer’s actions were unreasonable and they knew it (or should have known it). If they’re creating obstacles for a valid claim without a legitimate reason, that’s bad faith. It isn’t always a denial. Sometimes it’s the runaround they give you, designed to make getting fair payment so exhausting that you eventually just give up.

Myth 4: Instacart’s Insurance Will Automatically Cover Everything for Its Shoppers

Insurance for gig workers is a complete mess, and it’s widely misunderstood. A huge number of Instacart shoppers just assume that this giant tech company has them fully covered if they get into a wreck while working. This mistake can be financially devastating. While Instacart does provide some insurance, it’s riddled with strict limits, conditions, and gaps big enough to drive a truck through.

For instance, Instacart’s coverage for shoppers is broken down into different “periods.” There might be one level of liability coverage while you’re actively driving to a customer’s house, a much lower level of coverage while you’re logged into the app and waiting for an order, and absolutely no coverage from them once you’re offline. So if you get into a motorcycle accident on your way home after your last delivery, Instacart’s insurance won’t pay a dime. You’re on your own. On top of that, even when their policy does apply, the coverage limits might be too low to cover a serious injury, especially with L.A. medical costs. The real terms are buried in the independent contractor agreement that most shoppers scroll past. Any gig worker has to read their platform’s policy and their own personal insurance to see where the gaps are, because there are always gaps.

Myth 5: You Can’t Fight Back Against a Large Insurance Company

This is exactly what the insurance companies want you to believe, that they’re a billion-dollar giant and you’re just one person, so you have to take whatever scraps they offer. It’s an intimidation tactic. While they certainly have a lot of resources, you are not helpless, especially when they’re acting in bad faith. The legal system gives you a way to hold them accountable. Filing a bad faith lawsuit is a serious move that can make an insurer pay for their misconduct. If a jury finds they acted in bad faith, the company can be forced to pay not just the original claim amount, but also extra damages for your emotional distress and financial losses, and sometimes massive punitive damages meant to punish them and stop them from doing it to others.

To fight back, you need to have your ducks in a row with a strong case and solid evidence. This is where you need help from a lawyer who specializes in these kinds of claims. A good personal injury attorney knows all the games insurers play and how to beat them. They can collect the right evidence, depose the adjuster, and even subpoena the company’s internal emails to show a pattern of unreasonable behavior, like in a recent case involving a crash in the Los Angeles Arts District. The California State Bar Association can help you find qualified lawyers for insurance disputes (calbar.ca.gov). You are not powerless. The law was created to protect people from these exact kinds of corporate abuses.

Dealing with the fallout from an Instacart motorcycle crash in Los Angeles is tough enough without getting pushed around by an insurer acting in bad faith. Knowing the truth behind these myths is the first step to protecting yourself and getting the money you’re actually owed. For more on this topic in a different context, you can check out our article on Boston Amazon DSP Accidents: Bad Faith Insurance in 2026. And if you’re curious about how technology is changing these claims, have a look at Georgia UberEats Moped Accidents: AI Notetakers in 2026.

What exactly is “bad faith” from an insurance company?

Bad faith is when an insurance company doesn’t live up to its legal and contractual duties. It happens when they unreasonably delay, deny, or underpay a valid claim, or use other dirty tricks during the settlement process.

How does Instacart’s insurance actually work for shoppers in California?

Instacart usually has some commercial auto liability coverage, but how much (if any) depends on your status in the app, actively delivering, waiting for an order, or offline. The specifics are buried in the independent contractor agreement you signed.

What’s the most important evidence for proving a bad faith claim?

You need everything. Detailed accident records, all your medical bills and reports, proof of every related cost, a log of every call and email with the insurer, and any written proof that shows them acting unreasonably or dragging their feet.

Can I sue my insurance company for bad faith if they denied my claim?

Yes. If your claim was valid and they denied it without a good reason, you generally have the right to file a bad faith lawsuit. A successful suit could get you the original claim money plus additional damages for the harm their actions caused.

Are there specific California laws against bad faith insurance tactics?

Yes, absolutely. California Insurance Code Section 790.03 lists out many specific “unfair claims settlement practices” that are illegal. This law is the foundation for most bad faith claims and protects consumers from all sorts of insurer misconduct.

Editorial Team

The Editorial Team at Motorcycle Accident Atlanta is a group of writers and editors who cover personal injury and workplace law in Georgia. They research each story and publish under a shared desk byline — experts in their fields, working as one team.